You must login (register) to review.
Reviewer: AllieT Signed [Report This]
Date: 25 Mar 2009 06:39 PM Title: Six - Monsoon Perspective

I really enjoyed this story, especially with Max apologising by bringing Alec's TV etc.  Also, I liked the repetative use of the analogy about weather to savour the type of mood.

My one thought, though, is that it ended a little abruptly with the single Alec POV paragraph.  Perhaps even a couple of more sentences in the middle making it into two paragraphs might help a little?

Reviewer: OneBadCat Signed [Report This]
Date: 24 Mar 2009 06:16 PM Title: Two - Breaking Up Is Hard To Do

Very nice. Unexpected switch of character there, but your writing is strong enough to smooth the abrupt change and before long I couldn't even remember there had been someone else first - in a good way! :P

Loving this line - She’d known when she planned out telling him the truth that he would argue with her, so she’d spent the morning mentally preparing herself to stand her ground.

Just perfect!!

Also - no longer hope, but desperation Very powerful even though I don't really care for M/L. Sniffles...

Really enjoying this. Can't wait to see where you take it...

Author's Response:

Thank you so much for reviewing.  I'm glad you thought that the writing was able to carry the jump from Alec's perspective to Max's.  I knew it would be a little disjointed when I had the idea, so I tried to at least keep some of the same themes going thru the first two chapters - starting out talking about the rain, moving into a flashback, ending with them both being pissy and getting drunk. 

And I understand what you mean about not caring about M/L; I don't really either.  I've always thought that to write a convincing break up scene, though, you have to lace it with a bit of the underlying substance of the relationship.  Otherwise it just seems contrived to me.  So, I'm sorry that you have to slog through a little M/L, and I hope you'll find the ending worth it.

Thanks again for reviewing, and especially for providing actual feedback on the writing - it's very helpful.

Reviewer: OneBadCat Signed [Report This]
Date: 24 Mar 2009 06:07 PM Title: One - Rotgut is Good for the Soul

Nice set-up. I like the pace and the clever interweaving of flashback and present timeline. It's very realistic in terms of characterisation, and it has enough to make me want to read more, to keep going and find out what's going to happen.

Well done...!

You must login (register) to review.